Well, I finally drank the iMTB kool-aid and replaced my worn out Hans Dampf with a Minion DHF up front. I also replaced my Bontrager XR2 with a Minion SS in the back, but I'll try to keep that mostly in the Minion SS thread.
Before the riding impressions, here are some measurements for the other bike nerds:
- 29x2.3" 3C/EXO/TR version
- It weighed in at 932g - Both tires came in very close to their claimed weights, the DHF was only 7g over (compared to my Hans Dampfs which usually came in about 35g over)
- After leaving it at 45psi overnight, it stretched out to exactly 2.3" casing width, with the knobs slightly narrower - this is on a 26mm inner width rim
- The old 2.35" HD's casing was bigger than the claimed 2.35" on this rim and the knobs stuck out even farther to 2.44"
- I ran it at 19psi, the same as the slightly wider HD I'd been running - I'm about 180ish geared-up.
I was a little unsure about the tire after I put it on, since it was noticeably narrower and more square profiled than the HD I was used to, but I figured it must work otherwise everyone wouldn't be raving about it here. I had thought about the 2.5" version, but it just seemed like overkill for my riding and a lot of tire to haul up the hills.
I took it out today for a quick spin at Oaks to test it out. It's probably not an entirely fair comparison since my HD was pretty worn at 1,000 miles, but I could tell the difference in the side knobs right away even on a climb! It just stuck to side-slopes and off camber sections in a way that I don't think the HD did even when it was new. I could pick almost any line I wanted and it would just stay where I pointed it instead of sliding downhill to the side. The Minion SS definitely helped with this in the back, too.
I headed over to Hawk to get a feel for it on the downhill (the real reason for getting it
). As others have said on this thread, it simply went where I pointed it and stuck to that line. Off camber, rocks, rocks with loose dirt over them ... it didn't matter! It just carved turns that felt sketchy before, letting me carry more speed through the turn. My first run down Hawk took 4 seconds off my time from just a couple of days ago, and felt more stable.
Next I went over to Mtn Goat Waterfall. It wasn't my cleanest run on that trail, but considering the conditions it was in, it was a great test on a lot of different surfaces. It stuck to the trail like a pair of 5-10's on flats, and got me out of trouble a few times. One ride and I'm sold!