mtbMike
iMTB Rockstah
You can go with an HMO and deal with a bit of extra attention to detail, and have a $20 copay....
Or you can go with a PPO and have more flexibility, but have to fork over 10% of the bill.
In our case, if we'd been on a PPO we'd have shelled out more than $12,000 for my wife's 2 knee replacements (which were done at St Jude Fullerton). Because it was done under the HMO we'd paid about $120 total upfront, a tad more in premiums over the years. But not that much. In the near future we'd pony up another $6K - $8K when I have to get a valve job.
So I have to spend a few minutes ensuring the paperwork is in order? Okay.
I had a vasectomy at Kaiser ages ago. I don't recall any onerous requirements. Made the appointment, showed up, snip snip. Done.
You're making too many assumptions based on your experience, which clearly isn't true for all. What you pay depends on your plan and not whether is is an HMO or PPO. I've had a PPO the last 24 years. I broke my femur, tore my ACL, MCL, LCL and both meniscus in 2009 up in Mammoth. I had surgery to repair everything but the ACL and spend 4 days in the hospital. I paid $50 out of pocket. I came home and the surgeon that was going to do my ACL surgery eventually suggested I hold off on PT because I would want me PT sessions saved for the ACL recovery. My wife told him her PPO insurance allows 100 PT appointment per year. The surgeon was shocked and said we better call because he's never heard of such a thing as most allow 24 max. We called and as usual, my wife knew what she was talking about. I went on to have PT and after PT (I never counted) until my ACL surgery in early November. I continued to have PT after PT.....and never paid out another dime with our PPO insurance.
When I went to have a vasectomy in May 1996, Kaiser required me to go to a two hour "class" which was held on a weekday evening at their facility 50 miles away from my home. You then have to have a meeting with the doctor, with your wife present and after 48 hours pass, you can make an appointment to get the procedure done, once again 50 miles from our house. I ended up waiting a year of two and by then we had switched to a PPO. I went into the doctors office, by myself, signed some papers and made an appointment for the next week to get snipped. All about 5 miles from my house.